Inflating a Super-Puff Planet

Super-puffs fluffy planets observed to have abnormally low densities are a problem. According to theoretical models, they shouldnt exist and yet weve already detected half a dozen of them with Kepler alone. A new study explores what theory might be getting wrong.A Fluffy PuzzleAmong the assortment of odd and unexpected exoplanets weve discovered through years of observing transits, super-puffs stand out as a peculiar puzzle. Super-puffs are planets with masses lower than that of Neptune ( 5 Earth masses), but with sizes equivalent to those of gas-giant planets (transit radii 5 Earth radii).Photoevaporation by a planets host can boil off the planets atmosphere. This process works all the more quickly if the planet doesnt have strong surface gravity to hold on to its atmosphere. [MPIA]This doesnt inherently seem problematic, until we consider our understanding of planet evolution. Given a super-puffs low density, its atmosphere should be tenuous at best; without strong surface gravity to contain it, the atmosphere should get boiled off by the planets host star within perhaps 1,000 years. The super-puffs we see are much older than this, and yet they still retain their extended atmospheres.Piling on further intrigue, transmission spectra of super-puffs show no evident spectral lines. Lines can be washed out by the presence of aerosols clouds and hazes made up of dust or liquid droplets but we wouldnt expect these heavier particles to be able to stay lofted high enough in a fluffy planets atmosphere to flatten out its lines.In a new study, scientists Lile Wang (Flatiron Institute and Princeton University Observatory) and Fei Dai (MIT and Princeton University Observatory) suggest a revamped theoretical model that solves both of these problems.Spectral strengths of the water feature vs. planet mass. Planets with masses lower than 10 Earth masses dont have strong enough gravity to avoid having their spectral features washed out by dusty outflows in the planet atmosphere. [Wang Dai 2019]Solutions in FlowWang and Dais model has a significant change from previous pictures: their proposed atmosphere is not static. Instead, they suggest super-puffs have atmospheres that contain outward flows, continually carrying very small dust grains to high altitudes.By populating the upper reaches of the atmosphere with dust, these outflows increase the overall opacity of the atmosphere, which prevents it from boiling off quickly. And the dust carried to the upper atmosphere indeed washes out the spectral lines, providing an explanation for the flat spectra we observe.The authors model one prominent super-puff, Kepler 51b, and show that reasonable outflow rates (a loss of just 10-10 Earth masses of atmosphere per year) can carry dust grains of 10 in size to high altitudes. They show that this process inflates the observed transit radius of the planet to the 7 Earth radii we see, and it also flattens the planets transmission spectra.Spotting Signs of DustThe Spitzer Space Telescope could be used to extend the spectral wavelength coverage of planets of interest. Planets with dusty atmospheres would look larger in optical than in infrared wavelengths. [NASA/JPL-Caltech]How might we verify that a planet has dusty outflows in its atmosphere? Wang and Dai point out that the apparent radius of such a planet will be wavelength-dependent: their model planet, for instance, would appear 1020% larger at wavelengths of 0.5 m than at wavelengths of 1 m.This phenomenon has already been observed for several exoplanets, and the authors suggest that we could extend the wavelength coverage for transmission spectra to identify signatures of dusty atmospheres in other planets. Should dusty atmospheres prove common among young, low-mass exoplanets, we clearly will need to reformulate how we think about these bodies.CitationDusty Outflows in Planetary Atmospheres: Understanding Super-Puffs and Transmission Spectra of Sub-Neptunes, Lile Wang and Fei Dai 2019 ApJL 873 L1. doi:10.3847/2041-8213/ab0653