Cryptic outgassing from the Southern Ocean during the Holocene

The Southern Ocean is an important pre-anthropogenic source of carbon to the atmosphere. When Southern Hemisphere Westerly Winds are shifted poleward, wind-driven upwelling brings carbon-rich deep water to the surface. Multiple studies have shown that this mechanism is particularly important during the last deglaciation and is partly influenced by climate and oceanographic change triggered by the Northern Hemisphere high latitudes and the tropics. Here we show that the middle Holocene, too, was an important time for increased upwelling. New paleoecological reconstructions, inorganic and organic geochemical data, and stable isotope data from lakes and peatlands on New Zealand's South Island and Subantarctic Islands show strong evidence for poleward-shifted Southern Hemisphere Westerly Winds during the middle Holocene. Warming in the northern hemisphere either weakens westerlies or shifts them southward, reinvigorating the CO2 outgassing from the Southern Ocean. However, if, like in the deglacial period, the Southern Ocean was a source of carbon to the atmosphere in the middle Holocene, why do we not see ice-core evidence for increased pCO2 of the atmosphere? To answer this question, we look north, to the peatlands of the sub-Boreal, Boreal, and Arctic regions. We find, using a new compilation of peatland carbon accumulation rate data, that the northern peatland carbon sink, which was not a factor in the deglacial carbon cycle, could be strong enough in the mid Holocene to counterbalance the increased outgassing. The peatland carbon sink is strongest at the same time as our records from the subantarctic show that the SHWW are in a weakened or poleward-shifted state. Our work shows how the subantarctic has revealed a globally important mechanism impacting the carbon cycle of the Holocene.