Gas Production Within Stromatolites Across the Archean: Evidence For Ancient Microbial Metabolisms

Identifying the presence of specific microbial metabolisms in the Archean is a fundamental goal of deep-time geobiology. Certain fenestral textures within Archean stromatolites provide evidence for the presence of gas, and therefore gas-releasing metabolisms, within ancient microbial mats. Paleoenvironmental analysis indicates many of the stromatolites formed in shallow, agitated aqueous environments, with relatively rapid gas production and lithification of fenestrae. Proposed gases include oxygen, carbon dioxide, methane, hydrogen sulfide, and various nitrogen species, produced by appropriate metabolisms. This study charts the presence of gas-related fenestrae in Archean stromatolites over time, and examines the potential for various metabolisms to produce fenestral textures. Fenestral textures are present in Archean stromatolites on at least four separate cratons from 3.5 to 2.5 Ga. Fenestrae are preserved in carbonate and chert microbialites of various morphologies, including laminar, domal, and conical forms. Extensive fenestral textures, with dozens of fenestrae along individual laminae, are especially prevalent in Neoarchean stromatolites (2.8 -2.5 Ga). The volume of gas within Archean microbial mats was estimated by measuring fenestrae in ancient stromatolites and bubbles within modern mats. The time needed for metabolisms to produce appropriate gas volumes was calculated using modern rates obtained from the literature. Given the paleoenvironmental conditions, the longer a metabolism takes to make large amounts of gas, the less likely large bubbles will remain long enough to become preserved. Additionally, limiting reactants were estimated for each metabolism using previous Archean geochemical models. Metabolisms with limited reactants are less likely to produce large amounts of gas. Oxygenic photosynthesis can produce large amounts of gas within minutes, and the necessary reactants (carbon dioxide and water) were readily available in Archean environments. In the absence of clear sedimentary or geochemical evidence for abundant hydrogen or oxidized sulfur and nitrogen species during stromatolite morphogenesis, oxygenic photosynthesis is the metabolism with the highest potential for producing fenestrae before the Great Oxidation Event.