Patchy distribution of magma that fed the Bishop Tuff supereruption: Evidence from matrix glass major and trace-element compositions

For more than 40 years, the Bishop Tuff has been the archetypical example of a singular, zoned magma body that fed a supereruption. Early-erupted material is pyroxene-free and crystal poor (<20 wt. %), presumably erupted from the upper parts of the magma body; late-erupted material is orthopyroxene and clinopyroxene-bearing, commonly more crystal rich (up to 30 wt. % crystals), and presumably tapped magma from the lower portions of the magma body. Fe-Ti oxide compositions suggest higher crystallization temperatures for late-erupted magmas (as high as 820 °C) than for early-erupted magmas (as low as 700 °C). Pressures and temperatures derived from major element compositions of glass inclusions led Gualda & Ghiorso (2013, CMP) to suggest an alternative model of lateral juxtaposition of two main magma bodies - each one feeding early-erupted and late-erupted units. Chamberlain et al. (2015, JPet) and Evans et al. (2016, AmMin) recently disputed this interpretation. We present a large dataset of matrix glass compositions for 161 pumice clasts that span the stratigraphy of the deposit. We calculate crystallization pressures based on major-element glass compositions using rhyolite-MELTS geobarometry, and crystallization temperatures based on Zr in glass using zircon saturation geothermometry. We apply the same methods to 1538 major-element and 615 trace-element analyses from Chamberlain et al. The results overwhelmingly demonstrate that there is no difference in crystallization temperature or pressure between early and late-erupted magmas. Crystallization pressures and temperatures are unimodal, with modes of 150 MPa and 730 °C (calibration of Watson & Harrison). Our results strongly support lateral juxtaposition of two main magma bodies. Smaller units recognized by Chamberlain et al. crystallized at the same pressures as the main bodies - this suggests the coexistence of larger and smaller magma bodies at the time of the Bishop Tuff supereruption. We compare our findings for the Bishop Tuff with results for very large and supereruptions elsewhere in the world. We argue that supereruptions typically mobilize a complex patchwork of magma bodies that reside within specific levels of the crust. They reveal moments of high-melt productivity in the crust, unlike what we observe in the Earth today.