The Age of the Moon

Knowledge of the age of the Moon is important for understanding the early evolution of the solar system, including the timing of the hypothesized Giant Impact (GI). There have been many attempts to determine the Moon's age, but significant disagreement remains with some authors favoring an early formation and others arguing for a relatively young Moon formed at 4.4 Ga. Attempts to date the GI indirectly through its effects on the asteroid belt are problematic as there is no way to uniquely ascertain the cause of the observed disturbances (e.g., GI or meteorite parent body breakup). Determining the timing of the Lunar Magma Ocean (LMO) crystallization provides a more direct constraint on the age of the Moon, but interpreting the chronologic significance of LMO products is complicated by the fact that the only rock samples available are breccias. A better approach is to construct a model age for the fractional crystallization of the LMO since this should provide a global signature. Zircons from the Apollo samples are ancient, robust against later disturbances, and amenable to precise U-Pb geochronology and Hf isotope analyses that can be used to construct Lu-Hf model ages for the silicate differentiation of the Moon. Previous isotopic studies of Apollo zircons yielded artificially young Hf model ages because of the (then unknown) effect of neutron capture on Hf isotopic ratios generated by long exposure to cosmic radiation, and were unable to determine whether or not the U-Pb dates were concordant due to insufficient precision of in situ dating techniques. We have addressed these issues by carrying out CA-ID-TIMS U-Pb geochronology on Apollo 14 zircon fragments, followed by Hf isotope determination by solution MC-ICP-MS on the same volume of zircon. By constructing Hf model ages from zircons that are concordant to the sub-permil level, we show that the minimum age for the end of differentiation of the LMO, and by extension, the formation of the Moon, is 4.52 ± 0.01 Ga.