Discrete dipole approximation models of chrystalline forsterite: Applications to cometary crystalline silicates
Abstract
The shape, size, and composition of crystalline silicates observed in comet comae and external proto-planetary disks are indicative of the formation and evolution of the dust grains during the processes of planetary formation. In this dissertation, I present the 3 -- 40 mum absorption efficiencies( Qabs) of irregularly shaped forsterite crystals computed with the discrete dipole approximation (DDA) code DDSCAT developed by Draine and Flatau and run on the NASA Advanced Supercomputing facility Pleiades. An investigation of grain shapes ranging from spheroidal to irregular indicate that the strong spectral features from forsterite are sensitive to grain shape and are potentially degenerate with the effects of crystal solid state composition (Mg-content). The 10, 11, 18, 23, and 33.5 mum features are found to be the most crystal shape sensitive and should be avoided in determining Mg-content. The distinct spectral features for the three shape classes are connected with crystal formation environment using a condensation experiment by (Kobatake et al., 2008). The condensation experiment demonstrates that condensed forsterite crystal shapes are dependent on the condensation environmental temperature. I generate DDSCAT target analog shapes to the condensed crystal shapes. These analog shapes are represented by the three shape classes: 1) equant, 2) a, c-columns, and 3) b-shortened platelets. Each of these shape classes exhibit distinct spectral features that can be used to interpret grain shape characteristics from 8 --- 40 mum spectroscopy of astronomical objects containing crystalline silicates. Synthetic spectral energy distributions (SEDs) of the coma of Hale-Bopp at rh = 2.8 AU are generated by thermally modeling the flux contributions of 5 mineral species present in comets. The synthetic SEDs are constrained using a chi2- minimization technique. The mineral species are amorphous carbon, amorphous pyroxene, amorphous olivine, crystalline enstatite, and crystalline forsterite. Using the DDSCAT computed absorption efficiencies for a large variety of forsterite crystal shapes, which are computed for 66 grain sizes between 0.1 -- 5.0 mum, the flux contribution of irregularly shaped forsterite is computed. The forsterite flux contribution is then summed with the amorphous and crystalline enstatite contributions to generate the total synthetic SED. The DDSCAT forsterite grain shape synthetic SEDs reveal that the crystalline silicates in the coma of Hale-Bopp are irregular in shape with two distinct shape characteristics related to specific formation mechanisms: 1) equant grains with sharp ( ≲ 90°) angles between the faces, edges, and vertices that formed as high temperature condensates in the inner 1 -- 3 AU radial region of the Solar System's protoplanetary disk; and 2) c-shortened platelet shapes that likely formed from collisional processing of the crystals. The 8 -- 40 mum silicate spectral features of Hale-Bopp's coma are compared to the silicate spectral features of the comae of 17P/Holmes during 2007 outburst and 9P/Tempel 1 during the Deep Impact experiment to show that the silicate features with crystalline resonances are remarkably similar. The similarity in silicate spectral features suggests that the grain populations in the comae of these comets are similar in shape, size, and compositon. However, Hale-Bopp is a nearly isotropic comet (NIC) that dynamically came from the Oort cloud, and 17P and 9P are ecliptic comets (ECs) that dynamically came from the Scattered Disk. The different dynamical source regions yet similar silicate (amorphous and crystalline) grain populations suggest that ECs and NICs innately have similar grains and that the typically weaker silicate features of ECs are an effect of the surface grains becoming compacted with numerous perihelion passages. Hence, the differences in silicate between ECs and NICs are the result of grain structure and not grain composition. (Abstract shortened by UMI.)
- Publication:
-
Ph.D. Thesis
- Pub Date:
- November 2012
- Bibcode:
- 2012PhDT.......280L
- Keywords:
-
- Mineralogy;Physics, Astrophysics;Physics, Astronomy and Astrophysics