Incorporation of crust at the Lesser Antilles arc
Abstract
Most convergent margin magmas exhibit geochemical characteristics of continental crust, incorporated via subduction of continental sediment into the arc source (mantle wedge) or via assimilation of continental crust by arc magmas en route to surface. Resolving which of these processes dominate at a given arc is important in avoiding the circularity of the question of the origin of the continental crust. The Lesser Antilles is built on oceanic lithosphere so in principle any crustal signature has been introduced via sediment subduction. Geochemical variations in magmas along the arc have been matched with the variations displayed in sediments outboard of the trench 1 . At about the same time, similarly comprehensive data sets were produced from along the Lesser Antilles, arguing that much of the geochemical diversity reflected crustal contamination rather than source contamination 2. These claims were based on; 1) correlations between isotopic ratios and indices of differentiation, 2) high delta18O, which argues for extensive interaction with material that has interacted with water at low T and finally the observation that the highest Pb isotope ratios in the lavas actually exceed the highest seen in the sediments. The latter problem has now been solved since a wider range of sediments have now been examined, with a section of black shales exhibiting remarkably radiogenic Pb isotopes 3 . We have re-examined the origin of geochemical variations by comparing two specific volcanoes, Mt Pelee in the centre of the arc and The Quill in the north 4. The idea is to explore differentiation trends at a given volcano, and back project them to reasonable primitive magma compositions. In that way we can account for geochemical effects resulting from differentiation, and focus on source variations (contributions from slab to wedge along the Antilles). From this we conclude that 1) both suites differentiate largely by amphibole-plag fractionation, along with contamination by the arc crust, and 2) the source at each volcano is modified by addition of sediment or melt thereof, +/- fluid, consistent with observed sediment compositions. We have also focussed on some of the most isotopically extreme rocks along the arc (at St Lucia), given that they are the most crust-like and therefore have either assimilated prodigious amounts of sediment, or incorporated massive amounts of sediment into their sources. Here we have found variations in 87Sr/86Sr in single feldspar crystals and high delta 18O in crystals. Both observations are consistent with crustal contamination rather than source contamination. The implication that a continental component is available in the arc lithosphere as an assimilant needs to be reconciled with geodynamic models for the arc. 1. White, W. M. & Dupre, B. (1986).. Journal of Geophysical Research 91, 5927^5941. 2. Davidson, J. P. 1987.. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 51, 2185-2198. 3. Carpentier, M., Chauvel, C. & Mattielli, N., 2008.. Earth and Planetary Science Letters 272, 199-211. 4. Davidson, J. P. and Wilson, B.M., 2011.. J. Petrol., 52, 1493-1531. doi:10.1093/petrology/egq095
- Publication:
-
AGU Fall Meeting Abstracts
- Pub Date:
- December 2012
- Bibcode:
- 2012AGUFM.V43G..02D
- Keywords:
-
- 1031 GEOCHEMISTRY / Subduction zone processes;
- 1037 GEOCHEMISTRY / Magma genesis and partial melting;
- 1065 GEOCHEMISTRY / Major and trace element geochemistry