Salty or Sweet: Exploring the Challenges of Groundwater Salinization Within a Sustainability Framework

In semi-arid to arid landscapes under intensive irrigation, groundwater salinization can be a persistent and critical problem, leading to reduced agricultural productivity, limited access to fresh drinking water, and ultimately desertification. It is estimated that in India alone, problems of salinity are now affecting over 6 million hectares of agricultural land. In villages of the Mewat district of Haryana in Northern India, subsistence-level farming is the primary source of income, and farming families live under serious threat from increasing salinity levels, both in terms of crop production and adequate supplies of drinking water. The Institute for Rural Research and Development (IRRAD), a non-governmental organization (NGO) working in Mewat, has taken an innovative approach in this area to problems of groundwater salinization, using check dams and rainwater harvesting ponds to recharge aquifers in the freshwater zones of upstream hill areas, and to create freshwater pockets within the saline groundwater zones of down-gradient areas. Initial, pilot-scale efforts have led to apparent success in raising groundwater levels in freshwater zones and changing the dynamics of encroaching groundwater salinity, but the expansion of such efforts to larger-scale restoration is constrained by the availability of adequate resources. Under such resource constraints, which are typical of international development work, it becomes critical to utilize a decision-analysis framework to quantify both the immediate and long-term effectiveness and sustainability of interventions by NGOs such as IRRAD. In the present study, we have developed such a framework, linking the climate-hydrological dynamics of monsoon driven systems with village-scale socio-economic attributes to evaluate the sustainability of current restoration efforts and to prioritize future areas for intervention. We utilize a multi-dimensional metric that takes into account both physical factors related to water availability as well as socio-economic factors related to the capacity to deal with water stress. This metric allows us to evaluate and compare water-driven sustainability at the village, block, and district levels in Northern India based on a combination of readily available census and water resource data. Further, we utilize a pressure-response framework that considers monsoonal dynamics and effectively evaluates the effects of intervention efforts over time. Our results indicate that in arid to semi-arid regions, where problems of groundwater salinity are paramount, scaling factors corresponding to salinity levels as well as the relative size of the saline zone must be incorporated into indicators of water access and availability to accurately reflect overall sustainability. More importantly, the results point towards the value of incorporating dynamic, multi-dimensional sustainability metrics into decision-analysis frameworks used to aid in resource prioritization and the evaluation of intervention efforts.