Recent terebratulide brachiopods: Do they faithfully record oceanographic conditions throughout ontogeny?

Brachiopods have commonly been used to infer secular changes in ocean chemistry over the Phanerozoic Eon since Lowenstam (1961) concluded that Recent brachiopod calcite was precipitated in equilibrium with seawater. In order to infer paleoenvironmental conditions with confidence, however, the impact of potential kinetic and metabolic fractionation effects on the final isotopic signature, as it varies among individuals, must be determined. In this study, we analyzed the oxygen and carbon isotopic composition of closely spaced (~2/mm) samples of calcite along growth transects from individuals of the rhynchonelliform brachiopod, Laqueus californianus. By combining local oceanographic information with knowledge of brachiopod shell structure and growth patterns through ontogeny, in individuals of different ages from the same locality that died simultaneously, we can address the fidelity of brachiopod shell calcite as both an environmental proxy and a recorder of biological activity among conspecific individuals, in real time. This is an essential, but largely ignored, component in the paleoenvironmental interpretation of brachiopod shell calcite. In May 2011, more than 75 live L. californianus specimens were collected by Dr. J. Barry at Monterey Bay Aquarium Research Institute (MBARI) from Monterey Bay at 160 m water depth (36.7322N, 121.9739W) and generously given to us for use in this study. The specimens range in length from 5.75 to 46.16 mm, representing a range of ontogenetic ages. Water temperatures at 160 m range annually from 8C in the spring/summer upwelling season to 10C during the winter, while salinity fluctuates from 33.76 ppt in the winter to 34.11 ppt in the summer. Daily temperature and salinity data collected by MBARI over three decades allow us to calculate approximate equilibrium calcite values. We use these values to evaluate the claim that brachiopods mineralize in isotopic equilibrium with seawater throughout their lifespan with minimal intraspecific variation. We also use the MBARI data to correlate annual temperature fluctuations with δ18O trends within the calcite to estimate ontogenetic ages and growth rates. Full-grown adults were 10-11 years old when collected live, and grow an average of about 4 mm/year over their lifespan, growing faster before sexual maturity and slowing down after. The early results of the ontogenetic sampling tracts indicate calcite δ18O and δ13C values are strongly positively correlated. This relationship suggests kinetic fractionation effects are likely influencing the isotopic composition of the shells. Cyclic isotopic fluctuations are also recorded, in accordance with seasonal temperature oscillations in Monterey Bay, apparent even at 160 m depth. In most of the specimens, the amplitudes of the isotopic fluctuations exceed those of the predicted equilibrium values. Furthermore, our data support the claim made by other researchers that the outer primary layer of the shell is significantly depleted in both oxygen and carbon isotopes, below the range of equilibrium calcite. Isotopic oscillations across individuals align reasonably well both with each other and with ambient water temperature patterns. These results suggest that intraspecific variability is low in L. californianus and that these organisms are recording their environment similarly.