Problems with the concept of deformation phases as illustrated for the Goantagab Domain, NW Namibia

The concept of deformation phases is one of the corner stones of structural geology and is used to reconstruct tectonic history in all metamorphic rocks. Despite its simplicity, however, there are situations where the concept breaks down. The junction of the Neoproterozoic-Cambrian Kaoko and Damara Belts in the well-exposed desert of Namibia is ideally suited for a critical assessment of our use of the deformation phase concept. Metaturbidites and granite intrusions in the Goantagab Domain at the junction of the belts record the amalgamation of the Congo, Kalahari and Rio de la Plata Cratons. The local structure is complicated, with km-scale sheath folds, and despite perfectly exposed geology over a large area, could only be reconstructed by detailed structural mapping. Structures can be subdivided into at least four sets, attributed to four deformation phases on the basis of overprinting relations. Three of these sets of structures, however, formed during the same tectonic event under similar metamorphic conditions but slightly different flow regime. These sets show unusual gradational “ring” transitions in space, where older DA structures are reoriented and overprinted by new structures DA+1 that have similar orientation, and seem to grade into DA structures outside the overprinted area. In the core of the Goantagab Domain, D2 is thus reoriented and overprinted by local D2b folds and foliations that have the same orientation and style as D2 structures outside the domain core. This kind of behaviour may be common in inhomogeneous non-coaxial flow in other, less well exposed terrains and would go there unnoticed, leading to erroneous interpretations. An additional general problem is that the geometry of critical structures is laterally highly variable because of changes in (1) lithology; (2) previous structure; (3) metamorphic conditions (4) orientation and geometry of stress and flow tensors and (5) finite strain magnitude. Of these, only (2) and (4) are relevant to understand local tectonics, while the other effects have to be filtered out. Work in the Goantagab Domain shows how such “expressions” of deformation can be organised. Foliation traces in metaturbidites of the Goantagab Domain, central Namibia. S2 and S2b show partially overlapping "ring" transitions