Performance of Buildings in the 2009 Western Sumatra Earthquake
Abstract
The M7.6 earthquake of 30 September 2009 in Western Sumatra, Indonesia caused significant damage and collapse to hundreds of buildings and the deaths of 1,117 people. In Padang City, with a population of about 900,000 people, building collapse was the primary cause of deaths and serious injuries (313 deaths and 431 serious injuries). The predominant building construction types in Padang are concrete moment frames with brick infill and masonry bearing wall systems. Concrete frames are common in multistory commercial retail buildings, offices, schools, and hotels; and masonry bearing wall systems are primarily used in low-rise (usually single story) residential and school buildings. In general, buildings that collapsed did not conform to modern seismic engineering practices that are required by the current Indonesian building code and would be expected in regions of moderate to high seismicity. While collapse of multi-story concrete buildings was more prevalent in older buildings (more than 10 years old), there were several newer buildings that collapsed. Primary deficiencies identified in collapsed or severely damaged buildings included: (a) soft or weak stories that failed in either by sidesway mechanisms or shear failures followed by loss of axial capacity of columns, (b) lack of ductile reinforcing bar detailing in concrete beams, columns, and beam-column joints, (c) poor quality concrete and mortar materials and workmanship, (d) vulnerable building configurations and designs with incomplete or deficient load paths, and (e) out-of-plane wall failures in unreinforced (or marginally reinforced) masonry. While these deficiencies may be expected in older buildings, damage and collapse to some modern (or recently rennovated buildings) indicates a lack of enforcement of building code provisions for design and construction quality assurance. Many new buildings whose structural systems were undamaged were closed due to extensive earthquake damage to brick infill walls, glass facades, ceiling systems and other architectural finishes. These demonstrated the importance of considering deformation compatibility and seismic considerations in the design and detail of architectural elements and non-structural components. Another important lesson learned from this earthquake is the critical role that buildings serve for vertical evacuation (refuge) from tsunami inundation in Padang and similar coastal cities in regions of high tsunami hazards. Severe traffic congestion immediately after the September 30 earthquake demonstrated that horizontal evacuation alone is insufficient to safely evacuate Padang City residents to high ground. Therefore, efforts must be stepped up to pre-screen, assess, and engineer buildings tha can be utilized for vertical evacuation.
- Publication:
-
AGU Fall Meeting Abstracts
- Pub Date:
- December 2009
- Bibcode:
- 2009AGUFM.U22B..03D
- Keywords:
-
- 7209 SEISMOLOGY / Earthquake dynamics;
- 7240 SEISMOLOGY / Subduction zones;
- 7299 SEISMOLOGY / General or miscellaneous