Linking suspended sediment transport metrics with fish functional traits in the Northwestern Great Plains (Invited)
Abstract
Loss of ecological integrity due to excessive suspended sediment in rivers and streams is a major cause of water quality impairment in the United States. Although 32 states have developed numeric criteria for turbidity or suspended solids, or both according to the USEPA (2006), criteria is typically written as a percent exceedance above background and what constitutes background is not well defined. Defining a background level is problematic considering suspended sediments and related turbidity levels change with flow stage and season, and limited scientific data exists on relationships between sediment exposure and biotic response. Current assessment protocols for development of sediment total maximum daily loads (TMDLs) lack a means to link temporally-variable sediment transport rates with specific losses of ecological functions as loads increase. This study, within the in Northwestern Great Plains Ecoregion, co-located 58 USGS gauging stations with existing flow and suspended sediment data, and fish data from federal and state agencies. Suspended sediment concentration (SSC) transport metrics were quantified into exceedance frequencies of a given magnitude, duration as the number of consecutive days a given concentration was equaled or exceeded, dosage as concentration x duration, and mean annual suspended sediment yields. A functional traits-based approach was used to correlate SSC transport metrics with site occurrences of 20 fish traits organized into four main groups: preferred rearing mesohabitat, trophic structure, feeding habits, and spawning behavior. Negative correlations between SSC metrics and trait occurrences were assumed to represent potential conditions for impairment, specifically identifying an ecological loss by functional trait. Potential impairment conditions were linked with presence of the following traits: habitat preferences for stream pool and river shallow waters; feeding generalists, omnivores, piscivores; and several spawning behaviors. Using these results, TMDL targets were proposed such as < 19 mg/l SSC and 1,500 mg/l-day dosage at the 95% recurrence frequency for feeding generalists and omnivores. In general, traits correlated with: 1) a broad range of SSC exceedance frequencies and flow stages, 2) exceedance frequencies near 90-95% occurring at moderate flow stages; and 3) exceedance frequencies near 0.01-10 % occurring during floods. Unstable channels were found to be greater in transported suspended sediment than stable channels over a range of concentration exceedance frequencies, and likely influence physical habitat quality. Pool-preference and gravel spawner traits were greater in stable channels than unstable channels. Overall, a functional traits-based approach utilizing concentration-duration-frequency characteristics of suspended sediment transport was successful in identifying potential “targets” for biological impairment due to excessive sediment, and will aid in developing sediment TMDLs.
- Publication:
-
AGU Fall Meeting Abstracts
- Pub Date:
- December 2009
- Bibcode:
- 2009AGUFM.H53I..02S
- Keywords:
-
- 1813 HYDROLOGY / Eco-hydrology;
- 1856 HYDROLOGY / River channels;
- 1862 HYDROLOGY / Sediment transport;
- 1871 HYDROLOGY / Surface water quality