Monopole clusters, center vortices, and confinement in a Z2 gauge-Higgs system

We propose to use the different kinds of vacua of gauge theories coupled to matter as a laboratory to test confinement ideas of pure Yang-Mills theories. In particular, the very poor overlap of the Wilson loop with the broken string states supports the 't Hooft and Mandelstam confinement criteria. However, in the Z₂ gauge-Higgs model we use as a guide we find that the condensation of monopoles and center vortices is a necessary but not sufficient condition for confinement.