Dynamic Screening in Thermonuclear Reactions

It has recently been argued that there are no dynamic screening corrections to Salpeter's enhancement factor in thermonuclear reactions, in the weak-screening limit. Two arguments were used: (1) the Gibbs probability distribution is factorable into two parts, one of which, exp(-βe_ie_j/r_ij) (β=1/k_BT), is independent of velocity space, and (2) the enhancement factor is w=1+β²e²Z₁Z₂<φ²> with <φ²>_k=<E²>_k/k² and <E²>_k/(8π)=(T/2)[1-ɛ^{- 1}(0,k)]. We show that both of these arguments are incorrect.