Does the Fine-Structure Constant Really Vary in Time?

We discuss how laboratory experiments can be used to place constraints on possible variations of the fine-structure constant α in the observationally relevant redshift interval z~=0-5, within a rather general theoretical framework. We find a worst case upper limit for Δα/α of 8×10^-6 for z<=5 and Δα/α of 0.9×10^-6 for z<=1.6. The derived limits are at variance with the recent findings by Webb et al., who claim an observed variation of Δα/α=-2.6+/-0.4×10^-5 at 1<z<1.6.