Critical mass transfer in double-degenerate Type Ia supernovae

Doubly-degenerate binary systems consisting of two white dwarfs (WDs) both composed of carbon and oxygen and close enough that mass is transferred from the less massive to the more massive are possible progenitors of Type Ia supernovae. If the mass-transfer rate is slow enough that the accreting WD can reach a mass of 1.38 M_solar, then it can ignite carbon degenerately at its centre. This can lead to a thermonuclear runaway and hence a supernova explosion. However, if the accretion rate is too high the outer layers of the WD heat up too much and carbon ignites there non-degenerately. A series of mild carbon flashes can then propagate inwards and convert the carbon to neon relatively gently. There is no thermonuclear runaway and no supernova. We examine the critical accretion rate at which ignition switches from the centre to the surface for a variety of WDs and find it to be about two-fifths of the Eddington rate. In a real binary star, the mass-transfer rate falls off as mass transfer proceeds and the system widens. Even if the initial transfer rate is high enough for carbon to ignite at the outer edge, if such rapid accretion were to persist, we find that it can extinguish if the rate drops sufficiently quickly. The interior of the WD remains carbon rich and, if sufficient mass can still be transferred from the companion, it can eventually ignite degenerately at the centre. The primary WD must be about 1.1M_solar or above and the companion about 0.3M_solar. Though WDs of such low mass are expected to be pure helium, we note that a star of initial mass 2.5M_solar has a CO core of about 0.3M_solar when it begins to ascend the asymptotic giant branch. Alternatively, if the accretion rate can be limited to a maximum of 0.46 of the Eddington rate, then a 1.1-M_solar WD accretes sufficiently slowly to explode from a companion WD of any large enough mass.