A reexamination of electron density diagnostics for ionized gaseous nebulae
Abstract
We present a comparison of electron densities derived from optical forbidden line diagnostic ratios for a sample of over a hundred nebulae. We consider four density indicators, the [O II] λ3729/λ3726, [S II] λ6716/λ6731, [Cl III] λ5517/λ5537 and [Ar IV] λ4711/λ4740 doublet ratios. Except for a few H II regions for which data from the literature were used, diagnostic line ratios were derived from our own high quality spectra. For the [O II] λ3729/λ3726 doublet ratio, we find that our default atomic data set, consisting of transition probabilities from Zeippen (\cite{zeippen1982}) and collision strengths from Pradhan (\cite{pradhan}), fit the observations well, although at high electron densities, the [O II] doublet ratio yields densities systematically lower than those given by the [S II] λ6716/λ6731 doublet ratio, suggesting that the ratio of transition probabilities of the [O II] doublet, A(λ3729)/A(λ3726), given by Zeippen (\cite{zeippen1982}) may need to be revised upwards by approximately 6 per cent. Our analysis also shows that the more recent calculations of [O II] transition probabilities by Zeippen (\cite{zeippen1987a}) and collision strengths by McLaughlin & Bell (\cite{mclaughlin}) are inconsistent with the observations at the high and low density limits, respectively, and can therefore be ruled out. We confirm the earlier result of Copetti & Writzl (\cite{copetti2002}) that the [O II] transition probabilities calculated by Wiese et al. (\cite{wiese}) yield electron densities systematically lower than those deduced from the [S II] λ6716/λ6731 doublet ratio and that the discrepancy is most likely caused by errors in the transition probabilities calculated by Wiese et al. (\cite{wiese}). Using our default atomic data set for [O II], we find that Ne([O II]) ⪉ Ne([S II]) ≈ Ne([Cl III])< Ne([Ar IV]).
- Publication:
-
Astronomy and Astrophysics
- Pub Date:
- December 2004
- DOI:
- 10.1051/0004-6361:20041470
- arXiv:
- arXiv:astro-ph/0408040
- Bibcode:
- 2004A&A...427..873W
- Keywords:
-
- atomic data;
- ISM: lines and bands;
- ISM: planetary nebulae: general;
- Astrophysics
- E-Print:
- 15 pages, 13 figures, 7 tables, accepted for publication in A&