Distribution of Bayes' factor

The ratio of Bayesian evidences is a popular tool in cosmology to compare different models. There are however several issues with this method: Bayes' factor depends on the prior even in the limit of noninformative priors, and the Jeffreys scale, used to assess the test, is arbitrary. Moreover, the standard use of Bayes' factor is often criticized for being unable to reject models. In this paper, we address these shortcoming by promoting evidence ratios to frequentist statistics and deriving their sampling distributions. By comparing the evidence ratios to their sampling distributions, poor fitting models can now be rejected. Our method additionally does not depend on the prior in the limit of very weak priors, thereby safeguarding the experimenter against premature rejection of a theory with a uninformative prior, and replaces the arbitrary Jeffreys scale by probability thresholds for rejection. We provide analytical solutions for some simplified cases (Gaussian data, linear parameters, and nested models), and we apply the method to cosmological supernovae Ia data. We dub our method the FB method, for frequentist-Bayesian.