Products in double categories, revisited

Products in double categories, as found in cartesian double categories, are an elegant concept with numerous applications, yet also have a few puzzling aspects. In this paper, we revisit double-categorical products from an unbiased perspective, following up an original idea by Paré to employ a double-categorical analogue of the family construction, or free product completion. Defined in this way, double categories with finite products are strictly more expressive than cartesian double categories, while being governed by a single universal property that is no more difficult to work with. We develop the basic theory and examples of such products and, by duality, of coproducts in double categories. As an application, we introduce finite-product double theories, a categorification of finite-product theories that extends recent work by Lambert and the author on cartesian double theories, and we construct the virtual double category of models of a finite-product double theory.