The paradox of coherent photoproduction in incoherent interactions

The Good-Walker (GW) paradigm relates coherent and incoherent exclusive reactions to the average target configuration and its nucleonic and partonic fluctuations. In it, coherent photoproduction occurs when the target remains in the ground state, while, in incoherent photoproduction, the target breaks up. However, the GW paradigm fails to explain the observation of coherent vector meson photoproduction accompanied by nuclear breakup in ultra-peripheral collisions (UPCs) , and in peripheral relativistic heavy-ion collisions. In the latter, hundreds of particles can be created. This writeup will explore this paradox, and also present an alternate, semi-classical approach toward coherent production: adding the amplitudes with an appropriate propagator. The semi-classical approach explains the transverse momentum dependence of exclusive vector meson production in UPCs, but does not address the target final state. I will address these two approaches, and suggest possible future work to resolve the paradox \cite{Klein:2023zlf}.