Constraint on local definitions of quantum internal energy

Recent advances in quantum thermodynamics have been focusing on ever more elementary systems of interest, approaching the limit of a single qubit, with correlations, strong coupling, and far-from-equilibrium environments coming into play. Under such scenarios, it is clear that fundamental physical quantities must be revisited. This article questions whether a universal definition of internal energy for open quantum systems can be devised, setting limits on its possible properties. We argue that, for such a definition to be regarded as local, it should be determined by using only local resources, i.e., the open system's reduced density operator ϱ and its time derivatives. The simplest construction, then, would be a functional U (ϱ ,ϱ ̇) . We adopt the minimalist implementation of a bipartite quantum universe, namely, two qubits in a pure joint state, and show that the functional relationship cannot be that simple if it is to generally recover the well-established internal energy of the universe. No further hypothesis or approximation scheme was assumed. An illustrative counterexample is explored, and possible implications of the general constraint are discussed.