Impact of mode regularization for quasinormal-mode perturbation theories

We give theoretical insight into the critical problem of a modified cavity mode of an open resonator that is subject to a perturbation outside its cavity region. We utilize the framework of quasinormal modes (QNMs), which are the natural mode solutions to the open boundary problem with complex eigenfrequencies. This requires a non-Hermitian mode theory, typically using just a few dominant QNMs for resonant cavities, which are important for solving a wide range of problems in classical and quantum optics, including cavity quantum electrodynamics. We first highlight a fundamental problem with currently adopted formulas using QNM perturbation theory, when perturbations are added outside the resonator structure and present a potential step for solving this problem, connected to a regularization of the QNMs. We show several calculations of the QNMs and regularized QNM theory for simple one-dimensional cavities as well as a practical three-dimensional cavity structure. We first concentrate on the illustrative case of a one-dimensional dielectric barrier, where analytical QNM solutions are possible. We study the change of the mode frequency as a function of distance between the cavity and another smaller barrier structure (forming the outside perturbation). The results obtained from a few QNM expansion are also compared with exact analytical solutions from a transfer matrix approach. We show explicitly how regularization prevents a problematic spatial divergence for QNM perturbations in the far-field region, though eventually higher-order effects and multimodes can also play a role in the full scattering solution, and retaining a pure discrete QNM picture becomes questionable in such situations since the input-output coupling ultimately involves reservoir modes. To investigate a more practical cavity example, we also show results for a full three-dimensional plasmonic resonator of arbitrary shape and complex dispersion and loss, which again displays the divergent nature of the first-order mode change predicted from regular QNM perturbation theory, and an exponentially damped behavior from our regularized QNM theory.