Novel counterexample to the Nelson-Seiberg theorem

We present a new type of counterexample to the Nelson-Seiberg theorem. It is a generic R -symmetric Wess-Zumino model with nine chiral superfields, including one field of R -charge 2 and no R -charge 0 field. As in previous counterexamples, the model gives a set of degenerate supersymmetric vacua with a nonzero expectation value for a pair of oppositely R -charged fields. However, one of these fields appears quadratically in the superpotential, and many other fields with nonzero R charges gain nonzero expectation values at the vacuum, and so this model escapes the sufficient condition for counterexamples established in previous literature. Thus there are still open problems in the relation of R symmetries to supersymmetry breaking in generic models.