Reexamination of proton rms radii from low-q power expansions

Several recent publications claim that the proton charge rms radius resulting from the analysis of electron-scattering data restricted to low-momentum transfer agrees with the radius determined from muonic hydrogen, in contrast to the radius resulting from analyses of the full (e ,e ) data set which is 0.04 fm larger. Here we show why these publications erroneously arrive at the low radii.