First principles study of electronic structure for cubane-like and ring-shaped structures of M4O4, M4S4 clusters (M = Mn, Fe, Co, Ni, Cu)

Spin-polarized DFT has been used to perform a comparative study of the geometric structures and electronic properties for isolated M₄X₄ nano clusters between their two stable isomers - a planar rhombus-like 2D structure and a cubane-like 3D structure with M = Mn, Fe, Co, Ni, Cu ; X = O, S. These two structural patterns of the M₄X₄ clusters are commonly found as building blocks in several poly-nuclear transition metal complexes in inorganic chemistry. The effects of the van der Waals corrections to the physical properties have been considered in the electronic structure calculations employing the empirical Grimme's correction (DFT+D2). We report here an interesting trend in their relative structural stability - the isolated M₄O₄ clusters prefer to stabilize more in the planar structure, while the cubane-like 3D structure is more favorable for most of the isolated M₄S₄ clusters than their planar 2D counterparts. Our study reveals that this contrasting trend in the relative structural stability is expected to be driven by an interesting interplay between the s-d and p-d hybridization effects of the constituents' valence electrons.