Giant Planet and Brown Dwarf Formation

Understanding the dominant brown dwarf and giant planet formation processes, and finding out whether these processes rely on completely different mechanisms or share common channels, represents one of the major challenges of astronomy and remains the subject of heated debate. It is the aim of this review to summarize the latest developments in this field and to address the issue of origin by comparing different brown dwarf and giant planet formation scenarios with presently available observational constraints. As examined in the review, if objects are classified as "brown dwarfs" or "giant planets" on the basis of their formation mechanism, it has now become clear that their mass domains overlap and that there is no mass limit between these two distinct populations. Furthermore, while there is increasing observational evidence for the existence of non-deuterium (D)-burning brown dwarfs, some giant planets, characterized by a significantly metal-enriched composition, might be massive enough to ignite D burning in their core. Deuterium burning (or lack thereof) thus plays no role in either brown dwarf or giant planet formation. Consequently, we argue that the International Astronomical Union (IAU) definition for distinguishing these two populations has no physical justification and results in scientific confusion. In contrast, brown dwarfs and giant planets might bear some imprints of their formation mechanism, notably in their mean density and the physical properties of their atmosphere. Future direct imaging surveys will undoubtedly provide crucial information and perhaps provide some clear observational diagnostics to unambiguously distinguish these different astrophysical objects.