Integrable Scalar Cosmologies I. Foundations and links with String Theory

We build a number of integrable one-scalar spatially flat cosmologies, which play a natural role in inflationary scenarios, examine their behavior in several cases and draw from them some general lessons on this type of systems, whose potentials involve combinations of exponential functions, and on similar non-integrable ones. These include the impossibility for the scalar to emerge from the initial singularity descending along asymptotically exponential potentials with logarithmic slopes exceeding a critical value (“climbing phenomenon”) and the inevitable collapse in a Big Crunch whenever the scalar tries to settle at negative extrema of the potential. We also elaborate on the links between these types of potentials and “brane supersymmetry breaking”, a mechanism that ties together string scale and scale of supersymmetry breaking in a class of orientifold models.

Our Universe is highly isotropic and homogeneous at large scales, while its current state of acceleration is well accounted for by a small positive cosmological constant;

Our Universe is spatially flat, which brings to the forefront metrics of the form ds²=e dt²-a²(t) dxṡdx. Special “gauge functions” B(t) can result in simpler expressions for the scale factor a(t), which becomes a quantity of utmost interest for Theoretical Physics;

Vacuum energy accounts for about 70% of the present contents of the Universe, dark matter of unknown origin for another 24%, so that only 6% is left for conventional baryonic matter in the form of luminous stars and galaxies.

The climbing phenomenon, whereby the scalar field cannot emerge from the initial singularity climbing down potentials that are asymptotically exponential with logarithmic slopes exceeding a critical value. Or, if you will, the impossibility for scalar fields to overcome, in a contracting phase, the attractive force of such potential ends. The physical meaning of this phenomenon was first elucidated in [18] in the simple exponential potential, although the corresponding solutions have a long history [19,20]. Possible imprints on the low-ℓ tail of the CMB power spectrum were then discussed in [21], while an analysis of the mechanism near the initial singularity was recently presented in [22];

The eventual collapse in a Big Crunch of systems of this type whenever the scalar tends to settle at a negative extremum of the potential V(ϕ). This was expected: it reflects the fact that AdS has no spatially flat metrics, or that negative extrema are non-admissible fixed points for the corresponding dynamical systems.

The fields hⁱ associated with the Cartan generators of the Lie algebra of G, whose number equals the rank r of the coset and whose kinetic terms, determined by the invariant metric of G/H, are canonical up to an overall constant;

The axions b^I associated with the roots of the Lie algebra of G, whose kinetic terms depend instead on both the Cartan fields hⁱ and the b^I.

Can the integrable models that we have identified be realized within conventional gauged Supergravity, and for what choices of fluxes? This proviso is important, since some of the simplest potentials in our list do appear, albeit in versions where SUSY is non-linearly realized.

Can integrable potentials provide interesting insights on inflationary scenarios behind the slow-roll regime, in addition to those encoded by the single-exponential potential, the simplest member of the set, that already revealed the existence of the climbing phenomenon?

How much can one learn from integrable potentials about Cosmology with similar non-integrable potentials?

The first question is perhaps the most difficult one, but it is also particularly interesting since a proper understanding of the issue will encode low-energy manifestations of non-perturbative string effects present in these contexts even with supersymmetry broken at high scales. It will be dealt with in detail elsewhere [27].The second question has encouraging answers. There are indeed two classes of handily integrable models where an early climbing phase leaves way to inflation during the ensuing descent (models (2) and (9) in Table 1). This setting can leave interesting imprints on the low-ℓ portion of the CMB power spectrum [21] that are qualitatively along the lines of WMAP and PLANCK data and is close to BSB orientifold models, although not quite identical to them. Model (6) in Table 1 is perhaps the most interesting of all the examples that we are presenting, since it can even combine, in a rather elegant and relatively handy fashion, an early climbing phase with tens of e-folds of slow-roll inflation and with a graceful exit to an eventual phase of decelerated expansion.Finally, the extensive literature on two-dimensional dynamical systems implies a positive answer to the third question. It turns out, in fact, that the dynamical system counterparts of our cosmological equations experience behaviors that are largely determined by the nature of their fixed points, and more specifically by the eigenvalues of their linear approximations in the vicinity of them. As a result, when an integrable potential has the same type of fixed points as a physically interesting non-integrable one, its exact solutions are expected to provide trustable clues on the actual physical system. This result is very appealing, despite the absence of general estimates of the error, and will be illustrated further in [27] comparing analytical and numerical solutions for interesting families of potential wells that include the physically relevant case of the STU model [28].Summarizing, we have constructed a wide list of one-field integrable cosmologies and we have examined in detail the properties of their most significant solutions, arriving in this fashion at a qualitative grasp of the general case. We have also addressed the question of whether the integrable models provide valuable approximations of similar non-integrable models, and in this respect we have obtained encouraging results that find a rationale in the ascertained behavior of corresponding two-dimensional dynamical systems.The structure of the paper is as follows. In Section 2 we derive an effective dynamical model that encompasses the possible d-dimensional Friedman-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker (FLRW) spatially flat cosmologies driven by a scalar field ϕ with canonical kinetic term and self interaction produced by a potential function V(ϕ). In Section 3 we describe the methods used to build integrable dynamical systems and identify nine different families of one-scalar cosmologies that are integrable for suitable choices of the gauge function B(t) of Eq. (1.1). In Section 4 we analyze the generic properties of dynamical systems in two variables, we describe the general classification of their fixed points and we illustrate the corresponding behavior of the solutions of Section 3. We then discuss in detail the exact solutions of several particularly significant systems identified in Section 3 and illustrate a number of instructive lessons that can be drawn from them. In Section 5.1 we describe the gross features of 26 additional sporadic potentials and elaborate on the qualitative behavior of their solutions, on the basis of the key lessons drawn from the simpler examples of Section 4. We also elaborate briefly on the links with other integrable systems. In Section 6 we illustrate how exponential potentials accompany in String Theory a mechanism for supersymmetry breaking brought about by classically stable vacuum configurations of D branes and orientifolds with broken supersymmetry and discuss their behavior in lower dimensions. Under some assumptions that are spelled out in Section 6, we also describe the types of exponential potentials that can emerge, in four dimensions, from various types of branes present in String Theory. Insofar as possible, we work in a generic number of dimensions, but with critical superstrings in our mind, so that in most of the paper 4⩽d⩽10. Finally Section 7 contains our conclusions, an assessment of our current views on the role of integrability in cosmological models emerging from a Fundamental Theory and some anticipations of results that are going to appear elsewhere [27,29].