Cuts, cancellations and the closed time path: The soft leptogenesis example
Abstract
By including all leading quantum-statistical effects at finite temperature, we show that no net asymmetry of leptons and sleptons is generated from soft leptogenesis, save the possible contribution from the resonant mixing of sneutrinos. This result contrasts with different conclusions appearing in the literature that are based on an incomplete inclusion of quantum statistics. We discuss vertex and wave-function diagrams as well as all different possible kinematic cuts that nominally lead to CP-violating asymmetries. The present example of soft leptogenesis may therefore serve as a paradigm in order to identify more generally applicable caveats relevant to alternative scenarios for baryogenesis and leptogenesis, and it may provide useful guidance in constructing viable models.
For the vertex contributions, the intermediate on-shell particle is an out-of equilibrium singlet neutrino N (see Fig. 3). In this case, even when the subtraction of RIS is performed correctly,
On the other hand, when the RIS that is to be subtracted corresponds to a particle that is in equilibrium, such as the scalar Higgs doublet H1 in Section 4 (see Fig. 7), no asymmetry is generated in first place. This type of subtraction of equilibrium RIS and the consequent vanishing of the CPV asymmetry has been missed in the context of a different model in Ref. [9].
Alternatively, there exists a way of deriving the leptogenesis kinetic equations following a set of rules that intrinsically respect the unitary evolution of the system while sidestepping the pitfalls of the RIS procedure: the Closed Time Path (CTP) formalism [10-15]. Rather than formulating the problem in terms of S-matrix elements and classical particle distribution functions, the evolution of Green functions of the quantum fields is calculated. In particular, the imaginary parts of self-energies correspond to the inclusive decay and production rates that are necessary in order to track the evolution of the asymmetry. This way, the somewhat heuristic procedure of RIS subtraction can be avoided [16-31].In the present work, we calculate the source terms for the asymmetry using the CTP formalism. As our main result, we demonstrate that the resulting asymmetry of the lepton number vanishes even when taking into account quantum statistical corrections. In particular, the corrections associated with the internal lines precisely cancel those associated with the final states that are included in Refs. [6-8]. Consequently, the sum of the lepton and slepton asymmetries is zero.
- Publication:
-
Nuclear Physics B
- Pub Date:
- May 2014
- DOI:
- arXiv:
- arXiv:1307.0524
- Bibcode:
- 2014NuPhB.882..145G
- Keywords:
-
- High Energy Physics - Phenomenology;
- Astrophysics - Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics
- E-Print:
- 38 pages