Quantum theory as the most robust description of reproducible experiments
Abstract
It is shown that the basic equations of quantum theory can be obtained from a straightforward application of logical inference to experiments for which there is uncertainty about individual events and for which the frequencies of the observed events are robust with respect to small changes in the conditions under which the experiments are carried out.
There is no quantum world. There is only an abstract physical description. It is wrong to think that the task of physics is to find out how nature is. Physics concerns what we can say about nature [45]. Physics is to be regarded not so much as the study of something a priori given, but rather as the development of methods of ordering and surveying human experience. In this respect our task must be to account for such experience in a manner independent of individual subjective judgment and therefore objective in the sense that it can be unambiguously communicated in ordinary human language [46]. The physical content of quantum mechanics is exhausted by its power to formulate statistical laws governing observations under conditions specified in plain language [46]. The first two sentences of the first quote may be read as a suggestion to dispose of, in Mermin's words [47], the "bad habit" to take mathematical abstractions as the reality of the events (in the everyday sense of the word) that we experience through our senses. Although widely circulated, these sentences are reported by Petersen [45] and there is doubt that Bohr actually used this wording [48]. The last two sentences of the first quote and the second quote suggest that we should try to describe human experiences (confined to the realm of scientific inquiry) in a manner and language which is unambiguous and independent of the individual subjective judgment. Of course, the latter should not be construed to imply that the observed phenomena are independent of the choices made by the individual(s) in performing the scientific experiment [49].The third quote suggests that quantum theory is a powerful language to describe a certain class of statistical experiments but remains vague about the properties of the class. Similar views were expressed by other fathers of quantum mechanics, e.g., Max Born and Wolfgang Pauli [50]. They can be summarized as "Quantum theory describes our knowledge of the atomic phenomena rather than the atomic phenomena themselves". Our aim is, in a sense, to replace the philosophical components of these statements by well-defined mathematical concepts and to carefully study their relevance for physical phenomena. Specifically, by applying the general formalism of logical inference to a well-defined class of statistical experiments, the present paper shows that quantum theory is indeed the kind of language envisaged by Bohr.Theories such as Newtonian mechanics, Maxwell's electrodynamics, and Einstein's (general) relativity are deductive in character. Starting from a few axioms, abstracted from experimental observations and additional assumptions about the irrelevance of a large number of factors for the description of the phenomena of interest, deductive reasoning is used to prove or disprove unambiguous statements, propositions, about the mathematical objects which appear in the theory.The method of deductive reasoning conforms to the Boolean algebra of propositions. The deductive, reductionist methodology has the appealing feature that one can be sure that the propositions are either right or wrong, and disregarding the possibility that some of the premises on which the deduction is built may not apply, there is no doubt that the conclusions are correct. Clearly, these theories successfully describe a wide range of physical phenomena in a manner and language which is unambiguous and independent of the individual.At the same time, the construction of a physical theory, and a scientific theory in general, from "first principles" is, for sure, not something self-evident, and not even safe. Our basic knowledge always starts from the middle, that is, from the world of macroscopic objects. According to Bohr, the quantum theoretical description crucially depends on the existence of macroscopic objects which can be used as measuring devices. For an extensive analysis of the quantum measurement process from a dynamical point of view see Ref. [51]. Most importantly, the description of the macroscopic level is robust, that is, essentially independent of the underlying "more fundamental" picture [2]. As will be seen later, formalizing the notion of "robustness" is key to derive the basic equations of quantum theory from the general framework of logical inference.Key assumptions of the deductive approach are that the mathematical description is a complete description of the experiment under consideration and that there is no uncertainty about the conditions under which the experiment is carried out. If the theory does not fully account for all the relevant aspects of the phenomenon that we wish to describe, the general rules by which we deduce whether a proposition is true or false can no longer be used. However, in these circumstances, we can still resort to logical inference [37-41] to find useful answers to unambiguous questions. Of course, in general it will no longer be possible to say whether a proposition is true or false, hence there will always remain a residue of doubt. However, as will be shown, the description obtained through logical inference may also be unambiguous and independent of the individual.In the present paper, we demonstrate that the basic equations of quantum theory directly follow from logical inference applied to experiments in which there is uncertainty about individual events, the stringent condition that certain properties of the collection of events are reproducible, meaning that they are robust with respect to small changes in the conditions under which the experiments are carried out.- Publication:
-
Annals of Physics
- Pub Date:
- August 2014
- DOI:
- 10.1016/j.aop.2014.04.021
- arXiv:
- arXiv:1303.4574
- Bibcode:
- 2014AnPhy.347...45D
- Keywords:
-
- Quantum Physics
- E-Print:
- A link to a video presentation can be found at http://rugth30.phys.rug.nl/compphys0/publications/2014.html