Neutron scattering studies of K3H(SO4)2 and K3D(SO4)2: The particle-in-a-box model for the quantum phase transition

In the crystal of K₃H(SO₄)₂ or K₃D(SO₄)₂, dimers SO₄ṡṡṡHṡṡṡSO₄ or SO₄ṡṡṡDṡṡṡSO₄ are linked by strong centrosymmetric hydrogen or deuterium bonds whose OṡṡṡO length is ≈2.50 Å. We address two open questions. (i) Are H or D sites split or not? (ii) Is there any structural counterpart to the phase transition observed for K₃D(SO₄)₂ at T_c ≈ 85.5 K, which does not exist for K₃H(SO₄)₂? Neutron diffraction by single-crystals at cryogenic or room temperature reveals no structural transition and no resolvable splitting of H or D sites. However, the width of the probability densities suggest unresolved splitting of the wavefunctions suggesting rigid entities H_L1/2 -H_R1/2 or D_L1/2 -D_R1/2 whose separation lengths are l_H ≈ 0.16 Å or l_D ≈ 0.25 Å. The vibrational eigenstates for the center of mass of H_L1/2 -H_R1/2 revealed by inelastic neutron scattering are amenable to a square-well and we suppose the same potential holds for D_L1/2 -D_R1/2. In order to explain dielectric and calorimetric measurements of mixed crystals K₃D_{(1 - ρ)}H_ρ(SO₄)₂ (0 ⩽ ρ ⩽ 1), we replace the classical notion of order-disorder by the quantum notion of discernible (e.g., D_L1/2 -D_R1/2) or indiscernible (e.g., H_L1/2 -H_R1/2) components depending on the separation length of the split wavefunction. The discernible-indiscernible isostructural transition at finite temperatures is induced by a thermal pure quantum state or at 0 K by ρ.