Heat transport by turbulent Rayleigh-Bénard convection for Pr ≃ 0.8 and 4 × 1011 ≲ Ra ≲ 2 × 1014: ultimate-state transition for aspect ratio Γ = 1.00

We report experimental results for heat-transport measurements, in the form of the Nusselt number Nu, by turbulent Rayleigh-Bénard convection (RBC) in a cylindrical sample of aspect ratio Γ ≡ D/L = 1.00 (D = 1.12 m is the diameter and L = 1.12 m the height) and compare them with previously reported results for Γ = 0.50. The measurements were made using sulfur hexafluoride at pressures up to 19 bars as the fluid. They are for the Rayleigh-number range 4\times 10^{11} \lesssim Ra \lesssim 2\times 10^{14} and for Prandtl numbers Pr between 0.79 and 0.86. For Ra < Ra*₁ ≃ 2 × 10¹³ we find Nu = N₀Ra^γ_eff with γ_eff = 0.321 ± 0.002 and N₀ = 0.0776, consistent with classical turbulent RBC in a system with laminar boundary layers (BLs) below the top and above the bottom plate and with the prediction of Grossmann and Lohse. For Ra > Ra*₁ the data rise above the classical-state power-law and show greater scatter. In analogy to similar behavior observed for Γ = 0.50, we interpret this observation as the onset of the transition to the ultimate state. Within our resolution this onset occurs at nearly the same value of Ra*₁ as it does for Γ = 0.50. This differs from an earlier estimate by Roche et al (2010 New J. Phys. 12 085014), which yielded a transition at Ra_U ≃ 1.3 × 10¹¹Γ^-2.5±0.5. A Γ-independent Ra*₁ would suggest that the BL shear transition is induced by fluctuations on a scale less than the sample dimensions rather than by a global Γ-dependent flow mode. Within the resolution of the measurements the heat transport above Ra*₁ is equal for the two Γ values, suggesting a universal aspect of the ultimate-state transition and properties. The enhanced scatter of Nu in the transition region, which exceeds the experimental resolution, indicates an intrinsic irreproducibility of the state of the system. Several previous measurements for Γ = 1.00 are re-examined and compared with the present results. None of them identified the ultimate-state transition.