Anomalous Behavior of Solid He4 in Porous Vycor Glass

The low temperature properties of solid He4 contained in porous Vycor glass have been investigated utilizing a two-mode compound torsional oscillator. At low temperatures, we find period-shift signals for the solid similar to those reported by Kim and Chan [Nature (London) 427, 225 (2004)NATUAS0028-083610.1038/nature02220], which were taken at the time as evidence for a supersolid helium phase. The supersolid is expected to have properties analogous to those of a conventional superfluid, where the superfluid behavior is independent of frequency and the ratio of the superfluid signals observed at two different mode periods will depend only on the ratio of the sensitivities of the mode periods to mass loading. In the case of helium studies in Vycor, one can compare the period-shift signals seen for a conventional superfluid film with signals obtained for a supersolid within the same Vycor sample. We find, contrary to our own expectations, that the signals observed for the solid display a marked period dependence not seen in the case of the superfluid film. This surprising result suggests that the low temperature response of solid He4 in Vycor is more complex than previously assumed and cannot be thought of as a simple superfluid.