The Capra Research Program for Modelling Extreme Mass Ratio Inspirals
Abstract
Suppose a small compact object (black hole or neutron star) of mass m orbits a large black hole of mass M ≫ m. This system emits gravitational waves (GWs) that have a radiation-reaction effect on the particle's motion. EMRIs (extreme-mass-ratio inspirals) of this type will be important GW sources for LISA. To fully analyze these GWs, and to detect weaker sources also present in the LISA data stream, will require highly accurate EMRI GW templates.
In this article I outline the ``Capra'' research program to try to model EMRIs and calculate their GWs ab initio, assuming only that m ≪ M and that the Einstein equations hold. Because m ≪ M the timescale for the particle's orbit to shrink is too long for a practical direct numerical integration of the Einstein equations, and because this orbit may be deep in the large black hole's strong-field region, a post-Newtonian approximation would be inaccurate. Instead, we treat the EMRI spacetime as a perturbation of the large black hole's ``background'' (Schwarzschild or Kerr) spacetime and use the methods of black-hole perturbation theory, expanding in the small parameter m/M. The particle's motion can be described either as the result of a radiation-reaction ``self-force'' acting in the background spacetime or as geodesic motion in a perturbed spacetime. Several different lines of reasoning lead to the (same) basic O(m/M) ``MiSaTaQuWa'' equations of motion for the particle. In particular, the MiSaTaQuWa equations can be derived by modelling the particle as either a point particle or a small Schwarzschild black hole. The latter is conceptually elegant, but the former is technically much simpler and (surprisingly for a nonlinear field theory such as general relativity) still yields correct results. Modelling the small body as a point particle, its own field is singular along the particle worldline, so it's difficult to formulate a meaningful ``perturbation'' theory or equations of motion there. Detweiler and Whiting found an elegant decomposition of the particle's metric perturbation into a singular part which is spherically symmetric at the particle and a regular part which is smooth (and non-symmetric) at the particle. If we assume that the singular part (being spherically symmetric at the particle) exerts no force on the particle, then the MiSaTaQuWa equations follow immediately. The MiSaTaQuWa equations involve gradients of a (curved-spacetime) Green function, integrated over the particle's entire past worldline. These expressions aren't amenable to direct use in practical computations. By carefully analysing the singularity structure of each term in a spherical-harmonic expansion of the particle's field, Barack and Ori found that the self-force can be written as an infinite sum of modes, each of which can be calculated by (numerically) solving a set of wave equations in 1{+}1 dimensions, summing the gradients of the resulting fields at the particle position, and then subtracting certain analytically-calculable ``regularization parameters''. This ``mode-sum'' regularization scheme has been the basis for much further research including explicit numerical calculations of the self-force in a variety of situations, initially for Schwarzschild spacetime and more recently extending to Kerr spacetime. Recently Barack and Golbourn developed an alternative ``m-mode'' regularization scheme. This regularizes the physical metric perturbation by subtracting from it a suitable ``puncture function'' approximation to the Detweiler-Whiting singular field. The residual is then decomposed into a Fourier sum over azimuthal (e^{imϕ}) modes, and the resulting equations solved numerically in 2{+}1 dimensions. Vega and Detweiler have developed a related scheme that uses the same puncture-function regularization but then solves the regularized perturbation equation numerically in 3{+}1 dimensions, avoiding a mode-sum decomposition entirely. A number of research projects are now using these puncture-function regularization schemes, particularly for calculations in Kerr spacetime. Most Capra research to date has used 1st order perturbation theory, with the particle moving on a fixed (usually geodesic) worldline. Much current research is devoted to generalizing this to allow the particle worldline to be perturbed by the self-force, and to obtain approximation schemes which remain valid over long (EMRI-inspiral) timescales. To obtain the very high accuracies needed to fully exploit LISA's observations of the strongest EMRIs, 2nd order perturbation theory will probably also be needed; both this and long-time approximations remain frontiers for future Capra research.- Publication:
-
GW Notes
- Pub Date:
- February 2011
- DOI:
- 10.48550/arXiv.1102.2857
- arXiv:
- arXiv:1102.2857
- Bibcode:
- 2011GWN.....5....3T
- Keywords:
-
- gravitational waves;
- Capra program;
- extreme-mass-ratio insprials (EMRI);
- LISA;
- General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology;
- Astrophysics - Cosmology and Extragalactic Astrophysics;
- Astrophysics - Instrumentation and Methods for Astrophysics
- E-Print:
- 29 pages, 4 figures, invited review to appear in GW Notes (http://brownbag.lisascience.org/lisa-gw-notes/)