Tidal Mechanism as an Impossible Cause of the Observed Secular Increase of the Astronomical Unit

Krasinsky and Brumberg (<A >2004</A>, Celest. Mech. Dyn. Astron., 90, 267) reported a secular increase in the Astronomical Unit ( AU ) of 15 meters per century. Recently, Miura et al. (<A >2009</A>, PASJ, 61, 1247) proposed that angular-momentum transfer from the rotation of the Sun to the orbital motion of the solar-system planets may explain the observed increase of the AU . They assumed that the tidal effect between the planets and the Sun is the cause of this transfer. Here, we claim that a tidal effect cannot be a cause of this type of transfer to explain the increase of the AU .