Towards understanding the mass-metallicity relation of quasar absorbers: evidence for bimodality and consequences

One way to characterize and understand HI-selected galaxies is to study their metallicity properties. In particular, we show that the metallicity of absorbers is a bivariate function of the HI column density (N_HI) and the MgII equivalent width (W^λ2796_r). Thus, a selection upon W^λ2796_r is not equivalent to a HI selection for intervening absorbers. A direct consequence for damped absorbers with logN_HI > 20.3 that falls from the bivariate metallicity distribution is that any correlation between the metallicity [X/H] and velocity width (using W^λ2796_r as a proxy) cannot be interpreted as a signature of the mass-metallicity relation akin to normal field galaxies. In other words, damped Lyα absorber (DLA) samples are intrinsically heterogeneous and the [X/H]-W^λ2796_r or [X/H]-Δv correlation reported in the literature arises from the HI cut. On the other hand, a sample of MgII-selected absorbers, which are statistically dominated by lowest N_HI systems (sub-DLAs) at each W^λ2796_r, is found to have a more uniform metallicity distribution. We postulate that the bivariate distribution [[X/H](N_HI,W^λ2796_r)] can be explained by two different physical origins of absorbers, namely sight lines through the interstellar medium of small galaxies and sight lines through the out-flowing material. Several published results follow from the bivariate [X/H] distribution, namely (i) the properties of the two classes of DLAs, reported by Wolfe et al. and (ii) the constant dust-to-gas ratio for MgII absorbers.