How to form compact and other longer-lived planet-induced vortices: VSI, planet migration, or re-triggers, but not feedback

Past computational studies of planet-induced vortices have shown that the dust asymmetries associated with these vortices can be long-lived enough that they should be much more common in mm/sub-mm observations of protoplanetary discs, even though they are quite rare. Observed asymmetries also have a range of azimuthal extents from compact to elongated even though computational studies have shown planet-induced vortices should be preferentially elongated. In this study, we use 2D and 3D hydrodynamic simulations to test whether those dust asymmetries should really be so long-lived or so elongated. With higher resolution (29 cells radially per scale height) than our previous work, we find that vortices can be more compact by developing compact cores when higher-mass planets cause them to re-form, or if they are seeded by tiny compact vortices from the vertical shear instability (VSI), but not through dust feedback in 3D as was previously expected in general. Any case with a compact vortex or core(s) also has a longer lifetime. Even elongated vortices can have longer lifetimes with higher-mass planets or if the associated planet is allowed to migrate, the latter of which can cause the dust asymmetry to stop decaying as the planet migrates away from the vortex. These longer dust asymmetry lifetimes are even more inconsistent with observations, perhaps suggesting that discs still have an intermediate amount of effective viscosity.