Holocene temperature trends in the Northern Hemisphere high latitudes - model-data comparisons

Regional differences in Holocene climate trends in the Northern Hemisphere high latitudes are primarily determined by orbital-scale insolation variations and melting ice sheets. Previous inter-model comparisons have revealed that multi-simulation consistencies vary spatially. We compared multiple model results with proxy-based reconstructions in Fennoscandia, Greenland, north Canada, Alaska and Siberia. Our model-data comparisons reveal that data and models generally agree in Fennoscandia, Greenland and Canada, with the early-Holocene warming and subsequent gradual decrease to 0 ka BP (hereinafter referred as ka). In Fennoscandia, simulations and pollen data suggest a 2.0°C warming by 8 ka, but this is less expressed in chironomid data. In Canada, a strong early-Holocene warming is suggested by both the simulations and pollen results. In Greenland, the magnitude of early-Holocene warming ranges from 6.0°C in simulations to 8.0°C in δ¹⁸O-based temperature reconstructions. Simulated and reconstructed temperatures are mismatched in Alaska. Pollen data suggest a strong early-Holocene warming, while the simulations indicate constant Holocene cooling, and chironomid data show a stable trend. Meanwhile, a high frequency of Alaskan peatland initiation before 9 ka can reflect either high temperature, high soil moisture or large seasonality. In high-latitude Siberia, the simulations and proxy data depict high Holocene temperatures, but the signals are noisy owing to a large spread in the simulations and between pollen and chironomid results. On the whole, the Holocene climate trends in most regions (Fennoscandia, Greenland and Canada) are well established and understood, but important questions regarding the Holocene temperature change and mechanisms remain for Alaska and Siberia.