Evaluating the influence of stress on the dislocation creep flow law for quartz

Due to the abundance of quartz in the continental crust, quartz rheology is fundamental to our understanding of many geodynamic processes. Microstructures in many naturally deformed quartzites deformed at ductile conditions, indicate that dislocation creep is a common deformation mechanism in quartz at crustal conditions. The dislocation creep flow laws for quartz were constructed based on deformation experiments on aggregates at temperatures from 900 to 1100°C and strain rates of 10-5-10-6 s-1. Hirth et al. (2001) point out that these flow laws underestimate sample strengths for experiments conducted below 900°C; yet samples deformed as low as 700°C exhibit dislocation creep microstructures. To address this discrepancy, we compared 14 different studies on experimentally deformed wet quartzite aggregates ranging in temperature from 700 to 1100°C. Our analysis shows that two clear trends develop, one with a power-law stress exponent of n = 4 and the other, at a higher stress, with a stress exponent of n = 3. This change suggests a transition in the rate-limiting process; further, the conditions where the transition in stress exponent occurs correlate well with changes in quartz c-axis fabrics in general shear experiments. At low stresses, quartz fabrics are defined by a Y-max, indicating prism slip, while at higher stresses quartz fabrics are defined by basal slip. Our interpretation is that the c-axis fabrics represent the easy slip system in quartz and hypothesize that basal slip is rate-limiting at low stresses while prism is rate-limiting at high stresses. A change in the stress exponent has significant consequences for our understanding of high stress tectonic environments, such as the brittle-ductile transition and sediment rheology in a subducting slab.