What controls deformation in a bent three-dimensional orogen? An example from the Bolivian Andes

The width of orogens is thought to be affected by both erosional intensity and strength of the rocks. Along-strike variation of the orogen width can be expected to reflect shifts in these factors. An example of such variation can be found around the Bolivian orocline, which is a change in the orientation of the central Andes, in central Bolivia, from N-S south of 18°S to roughly NW-SE in the north. This bend coincides with 50% reduction in the width of the orogen east of the Altiplano, an approximately eight-fold increase in the annual precipitation, and the presence of a basement arch that reduces the thickness of relatively weak Paleozoic sediments upon which the orogen detaches. This has led to uncertainty about whether the growth of the orogen is controlled primarily by climate (erosion) or tectonics (strength of the basal detachment). We study deformation in a segmented orogen using 3D geodynamic models to understand how along-strike variations in rainfall and basal detachment strength affect orogen deformation and growth of the frontal part of the Andean fold-and-thrust belt (FTB). We calculate the visco-plastic deformation in the retro-wedge of an Andean-style orogen using the finite element software DOUAR (Braun et al. 2008) coupled to the surface process model FastScape (Braun & Willett 2013). The model design includes the basement, the Altiplano, and the FTB east of the plateau. A weak basal detachment zone is prescribed. Strain softening allows development of new faults and free evolution of the detachment zone. The effects of varying rock strength and varying precipitation are considered to determine the primary control(s) on the geometry and evolution of curved orogens. Results show that both increased precipitation and stronger detachment zone can explain differences in the width of the FTB, as reflected in the topography. These factors, however, lead to different structural evolution of the orogen: Weak basal detachment zone promotes growth of the FTB towards the foreland, whereas strong basal detachment keeps the deformation nearer to the plateau. Increased precipitation causes strong localization of the frontal thrust and no internal deformation in the foreland or near the plateau. Strike-slip faults are produced by variation in detachment zone strength, but not by shifts in precipitation rates.