Sensitivity of productivity and respiration to water availability determines the net ecosystem exchange of carbon terrestrial ecosystems of the United States

Interannual variability (IAV) of atmospheric CO2 is primarily driven by fluctuations in net carbon exchange (NEE) by terrestrial ecosystems. Recent analyses suggested that global terrestrial carbon uptake is dominated by the sensitivity of productivity to precipitation in semi-arid ecosystems, or sensitivity of respiration to temperature in tropical ecosystems. There is a need to better understand factors that control the carbon balance of land ecosystems across spatial and temporal scales. Here we used multiple observational dataset to assess: (1) What are the dominant processes controlling the IAV of NEE in terrestrial ecosystem? What are the climatic controls on the variability gross primary productivity (GPP) and total ecosystem respiration (TER) in the contiguous United States (CONUS). Our analysis revealed that there is a strong positive correlation between IAV of GPP and IAV of NEE in drier (mean annual precipitation: MAP < 750mm) western ecosystem, while there is no correlation between IAV of GPP and IAV of NEE in moist (MAP > 750mm) eastern ecosystem using observational dataset. Both βspatial and βtemporal of GPP and TER to precipitation exhibit an emergent threshold where GPP is more sensitive than TER to precipitation in semi-arid western ecosystems and TER is more sensitive than GPP to precipitation in more humid eastern ecosystems. This emergent ecosystem threshold was evident in several independent observations. However, analyses from 10 TRENDY models indicate current Dynamic Global Vegetation Models (DGVMs) tend to overestimate the sensitivity of NEE to GPP and underestimate the sensitivity of NEE to TER to precipitation across CONUS ecosystems. TER experiments showed that commonly used TER models failed to capture the IAV of TER in the moist region in CONUS. This is because heterotrophic respiration (Rh) was relatively independent of GPP in moist regions of CONUS, but was too tightly coupled to GPP in the DGVMs. The emergent thresholds at the ecosystem and continental scale may help reconcile model simulations and observations of terrestrial carbon processes.