Uranium isotope fractionation in biogenic carbonates: biological effects

Recent laboratory experiments have demonstrated small but potentially significant isotope fractionation ( 0.10 ‰ for 238U/235U) during uranium (U) incorporation into abiotic calcite and aragonite, with heavier U isotopes preferentially enriched in the precipitates [1]. In contrast, measurements of natural biogenic carbonates to date have not been able to resolve significant U isotopic fractionation from seawater although this might be expected given a typical measurement precision of ± 0.10 ‰. Determining whether or not biogenic carbonates display U isotope fractionation similar to abiotic carbonates could have important implications for understanding the mechanisms of U incorporation into various biogenic carbonates. Furthermore, because most marine carbonates are biogenic, the extent of isotopic fractionation, if any, could have important implications for the interpretation of sedimentary carbonates record similar to effects observed for Cr and B isotopes [2, 3]. To resolve this discrepancy, we utilized a higher precision 238U/235U method which uses larger sample sizes to improve measurement precision of natural samples to ± 0.02 ‰ (2 se, N = 6) [4]. Using this method, we have surveyed 238U/235U in primary biogenic skeletal carbonates including scleractinian corals, green and red algae, and mollusks, as well as non-skeletal carbonates such as stromatolites, ooids, and carbonate sands from the Bahamas, Gulf of California, and French Polynesia. New high-precision U isotopes measurements reveal that biogenic skeletal carbonates are typically 0.02 - 0.08 ‰ heavier than modern seawater. Scleractinian corals display values closest to seawater (- 0.37 ‰), while green algae, red algae, mollusks, and echinoderms display variable but larger extents of fractionation up to 0.08 ‰. The direction and magnitude of U isotope fractionation in these biogenic precipitates are generally consistent with results from abiotic coprecipitation experiments, but may be subject to variations in U speciation and carbonate chemistry at calcification sites. [1] Chen et a., (2016), GCA, 188, 189-207. [2] Wang et a., (2016), Geobiology, 5, 51-64. [3] Pagani et al., (2005) GCA, 69, 953-961. [4] Andersen et al., (2016) CG, 420, 11-22.