Post-Extinction Ecological Recovery of Marine Life Modes

A mass extinction is defined by a substantial increase in extinction rates, resulting in a loss of taxonomic and ecological diversity. Bush et al. (2007) defined ecological life modes as the feeding, motility, and tiering habits and organized them in a six-by-six "eco-cube" in which each section represented a life mode. In our research, we analyzed the ecological recovery of each life mode after the five mass extinctions. Using a fossil marine genera database, we compiled five heat maps that depict the recovery of the life modes by plotting the diversity of genera in each life mode two intervals before and five intervals after each mass extinction interval. New life modes seem to appear either immediately following or three or more intervals after a mass extinction, which indicates that ecological recovery is not a gradual process, but rather occurs in a punctuated manner. Furthermore, the "filling order" of new life modes differ in each extinction. However, some seem to have defined patterns, such as the Ordovician, where earlier post-extinction intervals experienced an increase in the diversity of erect (tiering) ecospaces, followed by that of surficial and shallow infaunal life modes. The Devonian mass extinction followed a similar pattern as the end Ordovician where erect organisms came first followed by surficial, deep-infaunal, and pelagic life modes. Conversely, intervals following the end-Permian mass extinction experienced a recovery in pelagic, freely-moving life modes, followed by a recovery in infaunal organisms and an explosion in semi-infaunal, erect, surficial, and pelagic ecospaces in the Ladinian. New life modes in the Triassic and Cretaceous mass extinctions did not seem to generate in a distinct pattern. Overall, we conclude that recovery patterns are unique depending on the cause of each mass extinction, and that any general tendency in post-extinction ecological recovery was most likely overridden by the environmental condition of the recovery intervals.