Is Tridymite at Gale Crater Evidence for Silicic Volcanism on Mars?

The X-ray diffraction (XRD) instrument (CheMin) onboard the MSL rover Curiosity detected 17 wt% of the SiO2 polymorph tridymite (relative to bulk sample) for the Buckskin drill sample (73 wt% SiO2) obtained from sedimentary rock in the Murray formation at Gale Crater, Mars. Other detected crystalline materials are plagioclase, sanidine, cristobalite, cation-deficient magnetite, and anhydrite. XRD amorphous material constitutes approx. 60 wt% of bulk sample, and the position of its broad diffraction peak near approx. 26 deg. 2-theta is consistent with opal-A. Tridymite is a low-pressure, high-temperature mineral (approx. 870 to 1670 deg. C) whose XRD-identified occurrence on the Earth is usually associated with silicic (e.g., rhyolitic) volcanism. High SiO2 deposits have been detected at Gale crater by remote sensing from martian orbit and interpreted as opal-A on the basis H2O and Si-OH spectral features. Proposed opal-A formation pathways include precipitation of silica from lake waters and high-SiO2 residues of acid-sulfate leaching. Tridymite is nominally anhydrous and would not exhibit these spectral features. We have chemically and spectrally analyzed rhyolitic samples from New Mexico and Iwodake volcano (Japan). The glassy (by XRD) NM samples have H2O spectral features similar to opal-A. The Iwodake sample, which has been subjected to high-temperature acid sulfate leaching, also has H2O spectral features similar to opal-A. The Iwodake sample has approx. 98 wt% SiO2 and 1% wt% TiO2 (by XRF), tridymite (>80 wt.% of crystalline material without detectable quartz by XRD), and H2O and Si-OH spectral features. These results open the working hypothesis that the opal-A-like high-SiO2 deposits at Gale crater detected from martian orbit are products of alteration associated with silicic volcanism. The presence or absence of tridymite will depend on lava crystallization temperatures (NM) and post crystallization alteration temperatures (Iwodake).