Impact of climate variability on N and C flux within the life cycle of biofuels produced from crop residues

Biofuels from agricultural feedstocks (lignocellulose) are under development to meet national policy objectives for producing domestic renewable fuels. Using crop residues such as corn stover as feedstock for biofuel production can minimize the risks associated with food market disruption; however, it demands managing residue removal to minimize soil carbon loss, erosion, and to ensure nutrient replacement. Emissions of nitrous oxide and changes to soil organic carbon (SOC) are subject to variability in time due to local climate conditions and cultivation practices. Our objective is to investigate the effect of climate inputs (precipitation and temperature) on biogeochemical greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions (N2O and SOC expressed as CO2) within the life cycle of biofuels produced from agricultural residues. Specifically, we investigate the impact of local climate variability on soil carbon and nitrogen fluxes over a 20-year biorefinery lifetime where biomass residue is used for lignocellulosic ethanol production. We investigate two cases studied previously (Pourhashem et al, 2013) where the fermentable sugars in the agricultural residue are converted to ethanol (biofuel) and the lignin byproduct is used in one of two ways: 1) power co-generation; or 2) application to land as a carbon/nutrient-rich amendment to soil. In the second case SOC losses are mitigated through returning the lignin component to land while the need for fertilizer addition is also eliminated, however in both cases N2O and SOC are subject to variability due to variable climate conditions. We used the biogeochemical model DayCent to predict soil carbon and nitrogen fluxes considering soil characteristics, tillage practices and local climate (e.g. temperature and rainfall). We address the impact of climate variability on the soil carbon and nitrogen fluxes by implementing a statistical bootstrap resampling method based on a historic data set (1980 to 2000). The ensuing probabilistic outputs from the DayCent model provide an increased understanding of expected ranges in fluxes attributable to climate variability. DayCent results for soil carbon change from the developed input datasets indicate that SOC is more strongly influenced by management practices than by variability in local climate even though the magnitude of this impact could depend on the local soil characteristics. Unlike carbon fluxes, soil N2O emissions are more sensitive to local climate variability than management practices suggesting that the difference in N2O emissions from the two management cases is not statistically significant. Therefore application of the high lignin byproduct material to land is a more efficient strategy in reducing soil carbon loss. However, although soil nitrogen fluxes might not be very sensitive to local climate when comparing synthetic to bio-based fertilizer applications, implementing the latter will eliminate the fertilizer production emissions on a biofuel production life cycle basis. Reference Pourhashem, G.; Adler, P., R.; McAloon, A. J.; Spatari, S., Cost and greenhouse gas emission tradeoffs of alternative uses of lignin for second generation ethanol. Env. Res. Let. 2013, 8, 025021