Secondary overprinting of S-Se-Te signatures in the Earth's mantle: Implications for the Late Veneer

Sulphur, Selenium and Tellurium are both chalcophile and highly siderophile elements (HSE) with near-chondritic ratios and absolute abundances in the terrestrial mantle that exceed those predicted by core-mantle differentiation[1]. These 'excess' HSE abundances have been attributed to addition of ca. 0.5% of chondrite-like material that hit the Earth in its accretionary stage between 4 to 3.8 billion years ago after core-mantle differentiation (Late Veneer[2]). Therefore, like other HSE, S, Se and Te are considered potential tracers for the composition of the Late Veneer, provided that their bulk silicate Earth abundances are properly constrained. In contrast to ca. 250 ppm S, Se and Te are ultra-trace elements in the terrestrial mantle. Like all HSE, they are furthermore controlled by base metal sulphides (BMS) and micrometric platinum group minerals (PGMs)[3]. This strong control exerted by the host mineralogy and petrology on the S-Se-Te systematics at both the micro-scale and the whole-rock scale makes detailed mineralogical and petrological studies of BMS and PGM a pre-requisite to fully understand and accurately interpret the whole-rock signatures. Here we combine in-situ sulphide data and detailed mineralogical observations with whole-rock S-Se-Te-HSE signatures of both lherzolites and harburgites from different geodynamic settings. We demonstrate that the near-chondritic Se and Te signature of 'fertile' mantle rocks (Se/Te ≈9×5) is not a primitive signature of the Earth's mantle, but rather reflects strong enrichment in metasomatic HSE host phases, which erased previous pristine signatures. Consequently, current attempts to identify a potential Late Veneer composition are seriously flawed because, neither refertilisation/metasomatism nor true melt depletion (e.g. harzburgitic residues) have been taken into account for the Primitive Upper Mantle composition estimate[4]. Our combined whole rock and in-situ sulphide data indicate a refertilisation trend towards sub-chondritic Se/Te ratios (i.e. Se/Te < 2). On the other hand, harzburgites that preserve depletion signatures show suprachondritic Se/Te ratios (< 31). Altogether this shows that metasomatic enrichment of mantle rocks may lead to a systematic bias and hence underestimation of the current Se/Te estimate of the primitive mantle. The metasomatic origin of the reported S, Se and Te ratios in peridotites that reflect the control of metasomatic BMS and PGMs[5;6] furthermore show that not all whole rock signatures in the Earth's mantle that scatter around near-chondritic values are primary and hence challenge the simple conception that these features may readily solve the long-standing conundrum of the Late Veneer composition. Refs: [1] Rose-Weston et al. (2009) GCA 73, 4598-4615; [2] Kimura et al. (1974) GCA 38, 683-701; [3] Lorand and Alard (2010) 67, 4137-4151; [4] Wang and Becker (2013) Nature 499, 328-331; [5] König et al. (2012) GCA 86, 354-366; [6] König et al. (2013, in press), EPSL.