Sill and Laccolith growth by Inflation and Propagation--just not necessarily at the same time

Sill and laccolith growth is achieved by two key mechanisms, inflation (vertical growth) and propagation (radial growth). Of the myriad of models proposed for magmatic intrusion, all are variations on the same theme--some combination of inflation and propagation. Because of the inherent observational limitations in studying actual high-level crustal magma emplacement, there remains a poor consensus on any preferred model. To gain insight we have performed a series of simple experiments using layered gelatin as a viscoelastic crustal analog, and molten wax as magma analog. Wax is injected from the base of the gelatin mold, begins ascent as a dike, and is captured by the overlying, more rigid, layer of gelatin. The use of a solidifying magma analog separates these experiments from other gelatin-based studies. When water is used, a common choice for magma analog, the intrusion propagates in an extremely smooth manner. However, at the tip of any magma filled crack, where thickness is at a minimum, propagation and solidification are in fierce competition. The introduction of solidification reveals that emplacement actually occurs as a series of ensuing pulses--at times propagating and inflating concurrently, and at other times growth is achieved solely through propagation, or solely inflation. Unlike models without solidification, here no single combination of propagation and inflation accounts for growth, but rather, the different styles of emplacement reflect the relative competitiveness of propagation and solidification at that time and location. When propagation is fast relative to solidification, growth is smooth, and propagation and inflation occur simultaneously. When solidification dominates, propagation ceases, and growth by inflation becomes the chief emplacement mechanism. Nevertheless, regardless of the strong effect of solidification, building backpressure and the associated crack stresses can disrupt the chill zone at the sill edge, and bring on rapid propagation of magma in conjunction with overall sill deflation. Because the competitiveness of solidification increases with decreasing propagation velocity, and because propagation velocity of a growing magma body must necessarily decrease with time, these mechanisms are a fundamental feature of any magma body that grows for any extended period. Generally, larger flux rates correlate to larger radii and thinner sills. For classical laccolith formation, flux rate must be slow enough for solidification to curtail propagation at an early stage, effectively limiting radial growth and promoting further growth solely via inflation. The effects of this overall process occurs on multiple scales, and the history of the chilled margins can be clearly seen with a series of essentially ';chatter rinds' marking the staccato process of emplacement.