Estimation of Gutenberg-Richter b-value using instrumental earthquake catalog from the southern Korean Peninsula

The b-value in Gutenberg-Richter relation is an important parameter widely used not only in the interpretation of regional tectonic structure but in the seismic hazard analysis. In this study, we tested four methods for estimating the stable b-value in a small number of events using Monte-Carlo method. One is the Least-Squares method (LSM) which minimizes the observation error. Others are based on the Maximum Likelihood method (MLM) which maximizes the likelihood function: Utsu's (1965) method for continuous magnitudes and an infinite maximum magnitude, Page's (1968) for continuous magnitudes and a finite maximum magnitude, and Weichert's (1980) for interval magnitude and a finite maximum magnitude. A synthetic parent population of the earthquake catalog of million events from magnitude 2.0 to 7.0 with interval of 0.1 was generated for the Monte-Carlo simulation. The sample, the number of which was increased from 25 to 1000, was extracted from the parent population randomly. The resampling procedure was applied 1000 times with different random seed numbers. The mean and the standard deviation of the b-value were estimated for each sample group that has the same number of samples. As expected, the more samples were used, the more stable b-value was obtained. However, in a small number of events, the LSM gave generally low b-value with a large standard deviation while other MLMs gave more accurate and stable values. It was found that Utsu (1965) gives the most accurate and stable b-value even in a small number of events. It was also found that the selection of the minimum magnitude could be critical for estimating the correct b-value for Utsu's (1965) method and Page's (1968) if magnitudes were binned into an interval. Therefore, we applied Utsu (1965) to estimate the b-value using two instrumental earthquake catalogs, which have events occurred around the southern part of the Korean Peninsula from 1978 to 2011. By a careful choice of the minimum magnitude, the b-values of the earthquake catalogs of the Korea Meteorological Administration and Kim (2012) are estimated to be 0.72 and 0.74, respectively.