Threshold Level of Harvested Litter Input for Carbon Sequestration by Bioenergy Crops

Due to the increase in the demands for bioenergy, considerable areas in the Midwestern United States could be converted into croplands for second generation bioenergy, such as the cultivation of miscanthus and switchgrass. Study on the effect of the expansion of these crops on soil carbon and nitrogen dynamics is integral to understanding their long-term environmental impacts. In this study, we focus on a comparative study between miscanthus, swichgrass, and corn-corn-soybean rotation on the below-ground dynamics of carbon and nitrogen. Fate of soil carbon and nitrogen is sensitive to harvest litter treatments and residue quality. Therefore, we attempt to address how different amounts of harvested biomass inputs into the soil impact the evolution of organic carbon and inorganic nitrogen in the subsurface. We use Precision Agricultural Landscape Modeling System, version 5.4.0, to capture biophysical and hydrological components coupled with a multilayer carbon and nitrogen cycle model. We apply the model at daily time scale to the Energy Biosciences Institute study site, located in the University of Illinois Research Farms, in Urbana, Illinois. The atmospheric forcing used to run the model was generated stochastically from parameters obtained from 10 years of atmospheric data recorded at both the study site and Willard Airport. Comparisons of model results against observations of drainage, ammonium and nitrate loads in tile drainage, nitrogen mineralization, nitrification, and litterfall in 2011 reveal the ability of the model to accurately capture the ecohydrology, as well as the carbon and nitrogen dynamics at the study site. The results obtained here highlight that there is a critical return of biomass to the soil when harvested for miscanthus (15% of aboveground biomass), and switchgrass (25%) after which the accumulation of carbon in the soil is significantly enhanced and nitrogen leaching is reduced, unlike corn-corn-soybean rotation. The main factor influencing the accumulation of carbon and reduction of nitrogen is the high carbon to nitrogen ratio in the biomass that is contributed as a litter from miscanthus and switchgrass when harvested. A nitrogen deficient environment in the top soil hinders microbial growth and therefore decomposition. In addition, lack of nitrogen fertilizer for miscanthus enhances even more the accumulation of carbon in the soil. On the other hand, nitrogen uptakes by miscanthus and switchgrass are not considerably affected due to a nitrogen fixation ability for miscanthus and fertilizer application for switchgrass. The simulation results obtained in this study show differences in the soil biogeochemistry induced by the different crops analyzed. We believe these results provide important findings about the impact of bioenergy crops on the carbon and nitrogen cycling in the soil.