Use of Geologic Mapping of the Medicine Lake Volcano in NE California to Constrain Interpretation of Cultural Uses of Rhyolite Obsidian

Recently published geologic mapping of Medicine Lake volcano in N. California (Donnelly-Nolan, 2010) provides a context for evaluating cultural use of Pleistocene rhyolitic obsidian at the volcano. The mapping identified an area of gravel that forms a small alluvial fan. The alluvial deposit includes abundant obsidian, some as water-worn cobbles, and some as flakes of obsidian. The alluvial fan is located about 3 km south of the nearest outcrop of obsidian, which is mapped as "rhyolite of Grasshopper Flat." This rhyolite unit has been identified over a distance of 30 km on the west side of Medicine Lake volcano as distributed chemically identical outcrops along a north-northeast trend. The aphyric obsidian provided excellent raw material for cultural use by Native Americans, and projectile point styles at nearby sites suggest up to 10,000 years of utilization. Obsidian in the fan deposit includes cobbles and flakes, some of which show definite signs of water transport, to a depth of >0.6 m. In addition to the definite anthropogenic flakes in the deposit, there are also unmodified obsidian pieces. The range of variation in the amount of water wear and other weathering on the obsidian makes it difficult to tell whether some of the flakes are anthropogenic or if they were broken by natural processes. It is also difficult to determine whether some of the definite anthropogenic flakes were created on site, or if all flakes in the deposit were created at a quarry upstream and transported with the other stream material. Lastly, some of the flakes display secondary flaking, perhaps related to recent logging activities or natural processes. The presence of anthropogenic flakes in the alluvium would indicate water transport during Holocene time, since there is little evidence of human occupation prior to the Holocene. Local scatters of clearly anthropogenic flakes are also present outside the stream deposit, indicating that at least some tool-making activity occurred in the vicinity. Glacial ice was present over the top of the volcano in latest Pleistocene time, but there is no evidence of ice in Holocene time, indicating that water capable of transporting the obsidian likely resulted from intense thunderstorm activity, or rapid melting of a thick snow pack upstream. High-resolution LiDAR will become available in the near future, allowing geologists and archaeologists an opportunity to identify additional deposits of water-transported obsidian, and possibly provide access to material for C-14 dating of the deposits. Establishing absolute dates for the flakes via C-14 analysis would assist in the interpretation of their origin.