Hot 'nough for ya?: Controls and Constraints on modeling flux melting in subduction zones

The qualitative concept of flux-melting in subduction zones is well established. Progressive dehydration reactions in the down-going slab release fluids to the hot overlying mantle wedge, causing flux melting and the migration of melts to the volcanic front. However, the quantitative details of fluid release, migration, melt generation and transport in the wedge remain poorly understood. In particular, there are two fundamental observations that defy quantitative modeling. The first is the location of the volcanic front with respect to intermediate depth earthquake (e.g. ∼ 100±40 km; England et al., 2004, Syracuse and Abers, 2006) which is remarkably robust yet insensitive to subduction parameters. This is particularly surprising given new estimates on the variability of fluid release in global subduction zones (e.g. van Keken et al. 2011) which show great sensitivity of fluid release to slab thermal conditions. Reconciling these results implies some robust mechanism for focusing fluids/melts toward the wedge corner. The second observation is the global existence of thermally hot erupted basalts and andesites that, if derived from flux melting of the mantle requires sub-arc mantle temperatures of ∼ 1300° C over shallow pressures of 1-2 GPa which are not that different from mid-ocean ridge conditions. These thermodynamic constraints are also implicit in recent parameterizations of wet melting (e.g. Kelley et al, 2010) which tend to produce significant amounts of melt only near the dry solidus. These observations impose significant challenges for geodynamic models of subduction zones, and in particular for those that don't include the explicit transport of fluids and melts. We present new high-resolution model results that suggest that a more complete description of coupled fluid/solid mechanics (allowing the fluid to interact with solid rheological variations) together with rheologically consistent solutions for temperature and solid flow, may provide the required ingredients that allow for robust focusing of both fluids and hot solids to the sub-arc regions. We demonstrate coupled fluid/solid flow models for simplified geometries to understand the basic processes, as well as for more geologically relevant models from a range of observed arc geometries. We will also evaluate the efficacy of current wet melting parameterizations in these models. All of these models have been built using new modeling software we have been developing that allows unprecedented flexibility in the composition and solution of coupled multi-physics problems. Dubbed TerraFERMA (the transparent Finite Element Rapid Model Assembler...no relation to the convection code TERRA), this new software leverages several advanced computational libraries (FEniCS/PETSc/Spud) to make it significantly easier to construct and explore a wide range of models of varying complexity. Subduction zones provide an ideal application area for understanding the role of different degrees of coupling of fluid and solid dynamics and their relation to observations.